Salesforce investors recently voted against the company’s compensation plan for top executives, citing concerns about equity awards granted to CEO Marc Benioff. The annual meeting held on Thursday saw 339.3 million votes in favor of the resolution to approve the compensation, while 404.8 million voted against it. Despite the board’s encouragement for shareholders to support the plan, the majority disagreed. This dissent was influenced by recommendations from shareholder advisory groups Glass Lewis and Institutional Shareholder Services advising against approving the plan.
For the 2024 fiscal year, Benioff received a total pay of $39.6 million, marking an increase from $29.9 million in the prior year. Although his salary remained unchanged at $1.55 million, he benefited from additional stock and option awards, as well as nonequity incentive plan compensation. The total sum also covered security fees that had not been previously invoiced to the company. Furthermore, in January, Benioff was granted a second long-term equity award worth $20 million by the compensation committee, recognizing the company’s successful transformation actions and strong financial performance. However, Glass Lewis criticized the discretionary equity grants as being substantial and lacking a convincing rationale.
As one of the largest shareholders of Salesforce with a stake valued at close to $6 billion, Benioff’s interests were deemed to already be aligned with those of other shareholders. Glass Lewis argued that the additional performance-based stock options and restricted stock units were unnecessary. The nonbinding vote at the annual meeting raised questions about the transparency and fairness of the executive compensation decisions. While the company stated that it values stockholders’ opinions, it remains to be seen how future compensation determinations will be affected by the vote.
Salesforce experienced significant growth in the 2024 fiscal year, with a 67% increase in shares and a substantial rise in net income and revenue. However, this positive performance was juxtaposed against the announcement of employee layoffs in January 2023, following pressure from activist investors for a more balanced profit and growth strategy. The decision to introduce a dividend for shareholders in February further underscored the shifts in Salesforce’s approach to financial management. Despite these changes, the company’s shares have seen a 2.6% decline year to date, indicating ongoing market skepticism.
The dissenting vote on Salesforce’s executive compensation plan reflects broader concerns about corporate governance, transparency, and aligning executive interests with those of shareholders. The scrutiny placed on Benioff’s compensation highlights the challenges faced by companies in balancing rewarding leadership performance while maintaining shareholder confidence and trust. Moving forward, Salesforce and other organizations must navigate these complexities to ensure sustainable growth and investor satisfaction.
Leave a Reply